James P. McCafferey Trophy Most Outstanding Defensive Player: East Division Awarded annually to the Outstanding Defensive Player in the Eastern Division. In 1995 the Award was presented to the Most Outstanding Player in the Southern Division. 2012 Shea Emry, Montreal 2011 Jovon Johnson, Winnipeg 2010 Markeith Knowlton, Hamilton 2009 Anwar Stewart, Montreal 2008 Doug Brown, Winnipeg 2007 Jonathan Brown, Toronto 2006 Barrin Simpson, Winnipeg 2005 Michael Fletcher, Toronto 2004 2003 Kevin Johnson, Montreal 2002 Barron Miles, Montreal 2001 Joe Montford, Hamilton 2000 Joe Montford, Hamilton 1999 Calvin Tiggle, Hamilton 1998 Joe Montford, Hamilton 1997 Shonte Peoples, Winnipeg 1996 Tracy Gravely, Montreal 1995 Tim Cofield, Memphis 1994 Tim Cofield, Hamilton 1993 Elfrid Payton, Winnipeg 1992 Angelo Snipes, Ottawa 1991 Greg Battle, Winnipeg 1990 Greg Battle, Winnipeg 1989 Greg Battle, Winnipeg 1988 Grover Covington, Hamilton 1987 James West, Winnipeg 1986 Brett Williams, Montreal 1985 Paul Bennett, Hamilton 1984 Harry Skipper, Montreal 1983 Greg Marshall, Ottawa 1982 Zac Henderson, Toronto 1981 Ben Zambiasi, Hamilton 1980 Tom Cousineau, Montreal 1979 Ben Zambiasi, Hamilton 1978 Randy Rhino, Montreal 1977 Glen Weir, Montreal 1976 Granville Liggins, Toronto 1975 Jim Corrigall, Toronto